Pdf we examine the patterns of media ownership in 97 countries. May 14, 2014 issues raised by media ownership by emma waite 2. Democracy is a form of government that allows the people to choose leadership. Often this takes the form of government ownership, barriers to entry for private media. The role of the media so far discussed is from a normative perspective, that is, how they ought to perform. I do believe that both sides have biasedness to a certain extend. It has a separate legal entity, perpetual succession and a. Normative roles, however, tell us little about the daytoday reality of what obtains in real life.
Farmers, farming associations, and cooperatives require transparent systems of land ownership and transfer and access to or distribution of public resources such as water for irrigation and roads for. The media brokers concentration and ownership of the press by ben bagdikian. Media concentration is the ownership of the mass media by fewer individuals. This is because they need to compete in the market. What are the advantages and disadvantages of freedom. Introduction the media and communication are closely related. Media ownership and democracy in the digital information age. At the time of inception, anzs ownership structure was 60% foreign and 40% local and government was not happy about this. Provisions of company law are applicable to government companies also. Advantages and disadvantages of goverment and private media. This leads to an underprovision of health care and education. Along with it, the individual can make decisions at his own pace which is usually fast and is naturally more connected with the content and the newspaper. Media ownership matters because parent companies exert a. Government, indepth interview, media, news, politicians, private officials 1.
In addition to ownership concentration of the mass media industry, content. Asare email protected, email protected senior lecturer and head of department department of political science university of ghana, legon abstract after two decades of constitutional rule with ghana having a vibrant and pluralistic media, the media is. State and government owned media are under direct state or ruling party control and may therefore tend toward favouring incumbent parties or candidates. Critics of this trend contend that media concentration threatens the marketplace of ideas and poses a threat to first amendment freedoms when the declaration of independence 1776, the constitution 1787, and the bill of rights 1789 were written, the mass media did not exist. The impact of zimbabwean media laws on the work of. Media ownership elizabeth hart introduction the new economy makes media dynasties among the most powerful organisations on earth. Deregulation of the media, therefore, stands out as a possible powerful policy lever. It has continued its control of the electronic media, with the zimbabwe broadcasting corporation, acting as a subsidiary of the government by denying access to the airwaves to opposition political groups, while giving the government and the ruling party unfettered access to the broadcast media. The fcc has explicitly based its media ownership regulation on this judicial understanding. The main advantage of privatization is to generate financial resources for the government to generate resources disinvestment of public sector enterprises. The obvious advantages to freedom is that every citizen becomes apart of the government system. Advantages and disadvantages of goverment and private. Merit goods are underconsumed in freemarket because people underestimate the personal benefits andor ignore the external benefits. Movies, books, and newspapers were censored, forcing the herald to resort to leaving blank spaces in its news columns in the 1960s to indicate where stories had been banned or censored.
Advantages and disadvantages of different types of media. The main advantage of media ownership is the potential to exert. The current debate over media ownership limits this book presents a critical view of the current state of commercial mass media in america. This question in turn is directly linked to the issue of media ownership state vs. Government, indepth interview, media, news, politicians, private officials. Private companies are more responsive to consumer demand.
The process by which an increasingly smaller number of companies own most media outlets. Besides the ownership system, another method of political control over the media and the engos in malaysia is the implementation of media and ngorelated laws and regulations, such as the printing. Advantages and disadvantages of state owned enterprises. Sky is a british satellite broadcasting, broadband and telephone services headquartered in london. While australian regulation only considers the supply aspect of. Protecting children from media according to beal, 2008, media can be defined as the various and different forms and technologies used for communication and channels of passing information or entertainment in the society. Mar 06, 2017 advantages in this kind of ownership, power comes in the form of individual and absolute control, which gives the person more secrecy in options. It examines the media through the lens of the public policy debates about limits on the number and type of media outlets that a single firm can own. Not withstanding, the private ownership are still control and influenced by the government and they works in the direction of the government because of their close relationship, thats why mr. Pdf media ownership is of interest to research on journalism due to the.
The harare offices had also been bombed in 2000 in the run up to the parliamentary elections. Censorship under the colonial regime, there was censorship of the media and the entertainment industry. The ethical implications of monopoly media ownership the. State owned enterprises help the government to control certain strategic sectors of the economy. The ownership of television news is even more concentrated, with a very few corporations controlling all of the major networks and cable news channels. Yet, television, and the other media, tend to destroy the very public. Media ownership regulation, the first amendment, and. The media entertainment and arts alliance meaa, which represents australian journalists, and other professional media groups, says the consolidated power of the large media owners is. Media ownership and control versus press freedom in a. The role of the media and investigative journalism in.
The influence of media ownership and control on media agenda. Ownership effects 1 effects of mass media ownership on. Mar 26, 2020 private media organizations, such as cnn or fox news, may focus heavily on the largest stories of the moment, while disregarding other events that draw fewer viewers. Media ownership regulation must utilize these insights to maximize. Advantages and problems of privatisation economics help.
Government ownership of the media, perhaps even as a monopoly, is then desirable for three reasons. Government s role in markets government can affect markets either through direct participation as a market maker or as a buyer or supplier of goods and services, or through indirect participation in private markets for example, through regulation, taxation, subsidy or other influence. A 2016 study by syracuse university concluded through dozens of owner and concessionaire interviews for usbased projects that there is a significantly higher likelihood of meeting cost and schedule objectives under p3 models compared with traditional public sector project delivery where a project is owned, managed, and financed by government. Task 1 understand the structure and ownership of the media sector. Media concentration the first amendment encyclopedia. Arguments against concentration of ownership rest on the premise that the unchecked concentration of power is undesirable. They see the current leadership class as the new haves of the postapartheid system. The rising advantage of publicprivate partnerships mckinsey. Of the firmlevel characteristics, we find that the soes size and industry significantly shape the privatizing governments crosslisting choices. In contrast, the public choice theory holds that a state owned media. An effective communication strategy usually uses a mix of at least 2 or 3 different types. What are the advantages and disadvantages of a partnership. The absence of restrictions on cross media ownership implies that particular companies or groups or conglomerates dominate markets both vertically that is, across different media such as print, radio, television and the internet as well as horizontally namely, in particular geographical regions. Advantages and disadvantages of partnership business.
Media ownership regulation in australia parliament of australia. Government regardless of its media hard copy, machinereadable, microfilm, or electronic is considered to be government records. Feb 15, 2018 media ownership is a very debatable topic. A public corporation is one that will go public by offering its stock to the public in the open market. The influence of media ownership and control on media. The present government has not gone that far, but it has appointed editors who follow government. Within the media watch program, we drew attention to the threat these issues pose to media pluralism in 2002 based on. Where proprietors have a high level of ownership of a media group.
The advantages and disadvantages of public corporation are important to know when wanting to convert your private business to a public corporation. Media ownership elizabeth hart in 2006, the bulletin magazine named murdoch the most in. Media ownership preface the issues of media ownership concentration and the formulation and implementation of an effective media legislation received considerable attention in recent years. It then lists 28 entitiessome, like the pennsylvania avenue development corporation, now defunctas being government corporations for the purposes of chapter 91 of title 31.
There are certain industries which if not monitored and controlled properly could pose serious risks to the public. Government vs private media ownership just live the days as. Media ownership and news coverage of international conflict. Serving the public interest is part of a longterm welfare policy of government. The reduction of direct government ownership over the whole media sector is. Government intervention to provide free education can lead to a significant improvement in the quality of life for people who are educated. Research into news and journalism indicates that, for media, government accountability and citizens engagement. I am sure we can agree to disagree on whether government owned media or privately owned media is better. A media conglomerate, media group or media institution is a company that owns large numbers of companies in various mass media. We examine the patterns of media ownership in 97 countries around the world. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the media. Government ownership is more pervasive in broadcasting than in the printed media. Government control of the media wallis institute of political economy. A government company is formed and registered under the companies act, 1956 as a public company or a private company.
Twenty years of south african democracy freedom house. Regulation of the media boundless political science. Media ownership and concentration in south africa oxford. Sky sky was founded in november 1990and was founded by rupert murdoch. Media conglomerates are generally controlled by a small group of people who are unelected and, in many ways, unaccountable to the community at large. A government company enjoys the following advantages or benefits.
This chapter describes media ownership and concentration in south africa. Zimbabwe press, media, tv, radio, newspapers television. The annual report of the working of the government company is required to be presented every year to the parliament or state legislature as the case may be. Effects of government ownership and control of mass media on.
But equally, there is a risk that state ownership can destroy value if best practices in ownership. Consequences of different forms of newspaper ownership. Often this takes the form of government ownership, barriers to entry for private media companies, and antidefamation laws. It was originally intended to serve as an authority to oversee the transition of the media from white minority control to. This is all the more surprising given that social media is the ideal tool for government departments to reach their audience citizens. It is a performance based issue that is reliant on current performance thus petrocik appears to agree with vavreck as far as the issue of the economy is concerned. The arguments or benefits of privatization maybe be as. Personally, i would prefer to have government media as they are more controlled despite of its disadvantages. Working together, to identify common goals and engage in an open and respectful manner, not only will help kenya improve the sharing of benefits of its oil, gas and mining resources, but is also important for preventing any further escalation of tensions and conflict. The importance of government social media contentgroup. A government company is formed easily as no statute is required to be enacted.
Many look at the government as a caring parent, accepting that this parent government retains its benevolent status in the eyes of the people. Implications for democratic governance in the fourth republic of ghana by mohammed s. The advantages of transferring government owned assets to the private sector are increased efficiency and profits, largely because competition incentivizes innovation and improvement. We then examine two theories of government ownership of the. Advantages and disadvantages of different types of media different media have different strengths, weaknesses, drawbacks, advantages and costs. When government planned to legislate against foreign ownership in the media, things began to change however. Different elements of a company working together to promote related products. The government has long indicated that it believed the rules to be anachronistic, and in 2002 unsuccessfully attempted to amend the cross media ownership restrictions. Advantages and disadvantages of public corporation.
Media regulation in australia takes a narrow approach to diversity, based on availability of traditional media, while omitting all online news, pay tv and public media. While this may be in the interests of government officials, it is often less clear how it serves the public good. In a notable paradox, however, citizens have also started to wonder how much this government really cares. Advertising regulation refers to the laws and rules defining the ways products can be advertised in a particular region. Pros and cons of government intervention economics help. After a quick look at the south african media scene, the chapter analyzes print media newspapers, book publishing, magazine publishing, audiovisual media radio, broadcast television, multichannel tv platforms, video channels, film, telecommunications media wireline and wireless telecom, and internet media internet.
Concentration of media ownership is a process whereby progressively fewer individuals or. Although there exists little comprehensive empirical and theoretical study on the issue. Media ownership regulation in australia parliament of. Social media is used by citizens all around the world. Media can be used for promotions of products and services, for instance, news paper, tvs, advertisements, radio announcements can be used as a means of. Another argument against private media is that private corporations generally offer far more centralized, standardized programming, creating a more homogenous media culture overall. The major effect of the laws is to prevent the common ownership of newspapers, television and radio broadcasting licences that serve the same region.
Ghana has had a long tradition of state ownership and control of the media, dating back to preindependence times. Government vs private media ownership just live the days. Advantage and disadvantages of means of media means of media are the instruments or devices to disseminate information to common people. Records may include, not only the deliverables specified by the contract, but can also include any supporting or backup data used to create the deliverables, and related health, safety and.
1373 718 1340 741 158 1238 1149 1327 584 654 447 570 956 897 1242 1200 1129 420 820 1002 959 723 277 770 952 1317 408 1477 405 553 377 1162 702 578